Chemical castration in Argentina for rapists?
Chemical castration in Argentina for rapists?
It was announced by officials in Argentina’s Mendoza province on the 21st of March, 2010, that chemical castration has been authorized for rapists convicted in the province. The move came after what the authorities called, a “significant rise” in the number of sexual assaults last year.
The law has largely been welcomed as a progressive law, which will, in the long run, prevent the recurrence of these atrocities as the convicted rapists will be prevented from doing it again. Rape, like pedophilia, is seen as a crime that has at its root a psychological affliction that prompts many rapists to become repeat offenders when released.
In the Mendoza case, the chemical castration will be administered only to those convicts who request it (in return for a reduced sentence) according to Argentina news sources, and they will receive counseling as part of a holistic approach to rehabilitation.
"By using medication that lowers the person's sexual desire and with psychological treatment, the person can be reintroduced into society without being a threat," Mendoza Governor Celso Jaque said.
Critics of the program point out that the treatment is reversible if the medication is not longer used, and that the effects on different people will be relative.
This is because rape is not a biological desire, it is seldom related to a desire for sex, rather it is psychological, the need to control someone or inflict pain on another individual. For this reason, the chemical castration will only take away a sexual delinquent’s chemical desire for sex, but his pathology will remain the same, his desire to make someone submit to his will.
In this way, rape with use of the penis may simply be replaced by rape with use of an object. And currently, Argentina does not recognize the use of an object as rape, but rather sexual assault, which carries a more lenient penalty.
The success of the program in Mendoza however, will determine whether it is feasible to apply it to the rest of Argentina. Although the law could be seen as a step towards drastically reducing the occurrence of such a heinous crime, it does raise some contradictions in the laws of the country in general.
A girl who is raped and then falls pregnant cannot have an abortion unless the pregnancy is putting her health or life at risk. Amnesty International calls this a violation of the victim’s human rights as it ‘revictimises’ them by forcing them to go through the trauma of labour, which is in effect the result of the trauma of rape.
Of course, the issue here becomes somewhat different. Abortion is about the life of the fetus, this is what the crux of the debate is centered around.
None-the-less, it does seem contradictory, perhaps even unfair, that a rapist can get a woman pregnant and then get a lighter sentence in return for having his testicles stop working temporarily, while his victim must carry, give birth to and then look after or give up for adoption, the product of his assault.
And just as he is released, to possibly commit the crime again, she will only be at the beginning of the road to some form of mental recovery.
Comments
More Argentina News
RSS-
Argentina to further limit access to dollars-source
BUENOS AIRES | Thu May 23, 2013 9:16am EDT BUENOS AIRES May 23 (Reuters) - Argentines will face a higher barrier to buying dollars under a new government policy limiting the amount of greenbacks they can withdraw using credit cards overseas, a government source with knowledge of the policy told Reuters on Thursday. Double-digit inflation and lack of confidence in the government's ...
-
Argentina Repsol struggle to bridge gap over YPF compensation
, there seems little prospect of a quick deal on compensation despite signs that both sides would rather avoid a costly, drawn-out legal battle.The Latin American country's lack of funds and its limits on the control private firms have over their investments - which could deter Repsol from accepting other assets in any settlement - pose major obstacles to a deal, according to ...
-
UAE President and Vice President Congratulate Argentina and Eritrea on National Day
May 23, 2013 - 02:22 - WAM ABU DHABI, May 23th, 2013 (WAM)-- Congratulatory cables were sent today by President His Highness Sheikh Khalifa bin Zayed Al Nahyan to the President of Argentina, Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner, and to the President of Eritrea, Isaias Afewerki, on the occasion of their respective countries' National ...
-
Music Review Pablo Ziegler Metropole Orkest - Amsterdam Meets New Tango
Gustavo Conde 's liner notes explain, is "a key exponent of contemporary Buenos Aires urban music, centered on pure tango" seasoned with "aspects of jazz improvisation." This is the new tango, a genre pioneered ...
-
Argentina’s ex-dictator Videla dead at 87
General Jorge Rafael Videla, who headed the bloody military junta that seized power in Argentina in 1976, died last Friday in a Marcos Paz prison cell. The coup that toppled the government of President Isabel Peron unleashed both economic devastation as well as mass repression against the working class for seven years (the "dirty war") until it fell following the defeat of ...
-
World Briefing | The Americas Argentina Increases of Cash Handouts to Poor
Argentina 's president has announced increases of as much as 35 percent in cash handouts to the poor, students, pregnant women and retirees. ...
-
Argentine ports strike stalls oilseed and grains exports at peak harvest time
Argentine longshoremen on strike at the peak of summer harvests exports have scores of grains ships delayed in and around due to a three-day-old conflict that threatens to bog down shipments at a time of heightened world demand for South American soy and corn, according to industry ...
-
Santa Fe Win 3-1 Unfazed by High Altitude in Cusco
BUENOS AIRES ...
-
Argentina calling Chinese firms
China, Argentina vow to enhance ties " (China Daily, May 11) Argentina can substantially increase the output of its agricultural products such as soybeans, corn, wheat and other food grains. Besides, it is already a major producer of beef and dairy products. Chinese companies should, therefore, think of starting large-scale joint ventures to produce non-genetically modified soybeans, ...
-
Argentina Judicial Reform A Farewell to thee Rule of Law and the Separation of Powers.
By Rodolfo Arrate (*) - The Argentine poet Jorge Luis Borges famously declared: "Democracy is an abuse of statistics". Observing the evolution of the political regime in Argentina nowadays, the poet’s sentence may well have turned into a ...
-
Argentine leader raises cash handouts 35 percent
Higher prices for its multiple sclerosis drug Rebif helped German pharmaceutical and high-tech materials company Merck KGaA post a 54 percent rise in first-quarter ...
-
Why you won’t be eating an Argentinian steak anytime soon
When global demand for Argentina's beef drove exports up in the early 2000s, farmer's didn't complain--they were turning a profit shipping out cattle. But locals did. The global demand drove up the price of beef domestically as well. Coupled with the country's 2001 default and subsequent inflationary problems, steak got really expensive. It all culminated in 2005, when ...
-
Argentinas Qom Indians ask President Fernandez for help getting ancestral lands returned
BUENOS AIRES, Argentina - Argentina's Qom Indians have asked President Cristina Fernandez for help in recovering some of their ancestral land. Justices met with Qom leader Felix Diaz and other tribal members but the governor of Formosa province, Gildo Insfran, was a no-show at the conciliation hearing, sending lower-level functionaries instead. The Qom refuse to move from land around the ...
-
Argentine Indians ask president for their lands
BUENOS AIRES, Argentina -; Argentina's Qom Indians have asked President Cristina Fernandez for help in recovering some of their ancestral ...
-
UPDATE 2-Strike stalls scores of grains ships in Argentina
Wed May 22, 2013 5:23pm EDT * U.S. grain stocks low this year after drought * World turns toward South America for soy, corn * High Argentine inflation fuels tough wage demands (Recasts with updated figures, new sourcing, adds context) By Hugh Bronstein BUENOS AIRES, May 22 (Reuters) - Scores of grains ships were delayed in and around Argentina on Wednesday due to a three-day-old strike by ...
-
Ex-Ford execs charged in Argentinian torture cases
BUENOS AIRES, Argentina--Three former Ford Motor Co. executives were charged Tuesday with crimes against humanity for allegedly targeting Argentine union workers for kidnapping and torture after the country's 1976 military coup. All three men are now in their ...
-
Argentine dictator Videlas burial protested
FILE - In this March 24, 1977 file photo, Gen. Jorge Rafael Videla is seen commemorating the first anniversary of the military coup in Asuncion, Argentina. The former Argentine dictator died of natural causes Friday, May 17, 2013, while serving life sentences at the Marcos Paz prison for crimes against humanity. Videla took power in a 1976 coup and led a military junta that killed thousands of ...
-
Cristina Fernandez We are Building an Argentina of Rights
Buenos Aires, May 22 (Prensa Latina) Argentina is building a country today where human, social and economic rights go hand in hand, assured President Cristina Fernandez at the inauguration of the restored Library at the National College of La Plata University. The facility is named Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo and is the third and final stage of the Comprehensive Recovery Plan for the National ...
Feature on Argentina
-
Chemical castration in Argentina for rapists?
Chemical castration of rapists seems a good way to prevent them from re-offending. But, if the 'treatment' is reversible by simply not taking the medicine anymore, and if taking the treatment get the rapist a light sentence, is it fair that the victim still has to carry his child if he makes her pregnant in the attack?
It was announced by officials in Argentina’s Mendoza province on the 21st of March, 2010, that chemical castration has been authorized for rapists convicted in the province. The move came after what the authorities called, a “significant rise” in the number of sexual assaults last year. Read more
News from around our Network
